Denial and Leadership
in Business Ethics Education: A Position Statement
Diane L. Swanson, Ph.D., Kansas State University
William C. Frederick, Ph.D., University of Pittsburgh
(Presented at the Business Ethics Symposium, Denver, October 31, 2003)
Business
ethics broadly defined: Ethics involves right or wrong actions taken
by corporations. In practice, ethics covers such areas as business
law (especially the new Sarbanes-Oxley law), public policy (new SEC guidelines),
organizational ethics (e.g., corporate governance), environmentalism
(sustainable business practices), and corporate social responsibility
(obligations to community and stakeholders). Given this context, ethics
courses are often labeled "business and society" or "social
issues in management."
The problem of denial: Business
schools have historically delivered education tainted by the myth of
neoclassical theory that economic decisions
are "value free." This myth, conveyed in curriculum that is
narrowly vocational and overly specialized, has denied ethics its rightful
place in business education.
The trend of downsizing
of ethics coursework: The language of accreditation used to point schools
in the direction of requiring a stand-alone course
in ethics. But in the early 1990s the accrediting agency, AACSB, approved
more flexible mission-driven standards that allowed ethics to be "flexified" or
scattered across curriculum. The downsizing of ethics courses that ensued
became a trend that has continued even in the wake of the corporate scandals.
To defend this alarming trend, a false dichotomy has been created. The
issue has been framed as a choice between (1) a stand-alone ethics course
or (2) integration of ethics across curriculum. In reality there is no
dichotomy. A whole cloth approach to ethics involves both endeavors.
The challenge of reversing
the trend: Top university administrators
need to apply budgetary pressure to reverse this trend. Students could
not learn finance, human resources or marketing principles if merely
tacked onto other courses. The same holds for ethics. Efforts to integrate
ethics across curriculum are laudable if anchored to some kind of foundational
course. A holistic approach to business ethics education is a simple
formula.
- A required
foundational ethics course is necessary.
- Efforts
to integrate ethics across curriculum should be a goal.
- Other
initiatives, such as hosting guest speakers, offering service
learning projects, and establishing endowed chairs
in ethics, are highly
desirable.
This standard supports cross-fertilization
of ideas across disciplines, especially since a core body of ethics
material is preserved for reference.
Otherwise, schools end up trying to "recreate the wheel" in
ethics.
Opportunities for
leadership: According to recent studies, a few of
the nation's business schools are exerting leadership and requiring ethics
coursework as a condition for integration. In light of AACSB weak standards
and the history of denial in business schools, these cutting-edge schools
are a main source of leadership in ethics education and deserve to be
supported by the corporate sector and publicly recognized.